UPSC Margin is a free study platform offering analytical concept notes, daily current affairs, and mock tests for UPSC Civil Services Prelims and Mains preparation. Built by an aspirant for aspirants.

Is UPSC Margin completely free?

All notes, daily current affairs, sectional tests, and full-length mock tests are free during the 3-month open-access window.

How are the mock tests structured?

Mock tests follow the exact UPSC Prelims format: 100 questions for GS Paper I with 2-hour timer, +2 marks for correct answers, and -0.67 for wrong answers. Each question has a detailed explanation.

UPSC Margin

Back to Notes

PolityFree till Sep 9

Governor: Powers, Discretion, and Controversies

July 20, 2026

TOPIC CLASSIFICATION

Subject: Polity — Constitutional Position of the Governor
Sub-topic: Governor — Appointment, Powers (Executive, Legislative, Financial, Judicial), Discretionary Powers, Sarkaria Commission, Punchhi Commission, Controversies
Mains GS Paper-II: Executive, Centre-State Relations, Federalism, Role of Governor.

EXAMINER REASONING

The Governor is the constitutional head of a state — the bridge between the Union and the state. The role is simultaneously ceremonial and political, with vast discretionary powers that have been the subject of intense controversy. Prelims tests: Article 155 (appointment), Article 156 (tenure), Article 163 (Council of Ministers), Article 200 (assent to bills), Article 356 (President's Rule), ordinance-making under Article 213. Mains demands: (a) the dual role — constitutional head vs. agent of the Centre, (b) discretionary powers — when can the Governor act without ministerial advice? (c) major controversies — Governors blocking bills, recommending President's Rule (Kerala 1959, Karnataka 2023, Maharashtra 2019, Punjab 2023), delaying decisions on Chief Minister claims (Goa 2015, Arunachal 2016), (d) the Sarkaria Commission (1988) and Punchhi Commission (2010) recommendations — appointment process, security of tenure, qualifications, (e) the doctrine of pleasure — Governor holds office "during the pleasure of the President" (Art. 156) — effectively the Union Government's pleasure. The examiner's favourite framing is: "Is the Governor the conscience keeper of the Constitution or an agent of the Centre?"

Core Concept

Constitutional Position of the Governor:

Aspect	Detail
Appointment	By the President (Art. 155) — on the advice of the Union Council of Ministers
Tenure	At the pleasure of the President (Art. 156) — usually 5 years
Qualifications

Governor: Powers, Discretion, and Controversies

July 20, 2026

TOPIC CLASSIFICATION

EXAMINER REASONING

Core Concept

Constitutional Position of the Governor:

Aspect	Detail
Appointment	By the President (Art. 155) — on the advice of the Union Council of Ministers
Tenure	At the pleasure of the President (Art. 156) — usually 5 years
Qualifications

Type	Specific Powers
Executive	Appoints CM and Ministers; appoints Advocate General, Chairman/members of State PSC; administration of Union Territories
Legislative	Summons/prorogues State Legislature; addresses first session; nominates 1 Anglo-Indian (if applicable); dissolves Assembly; reserves bills for Presidential consideration
Financial	Causes budget to be laid; constitutes State Finance Commission; sanctions money bills
Judicial	Power to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, or remissions (Art. 161); consultation in appointment of HC judges
Ordinance-making	Can promulgate ordinances when Legislature is not in session (Art. 213)
Discretionary	Appoints CM (if no clear majority); dismisses CM; recommends President's Rule (Art. 356); reserves bill for President (Art. 200); issues ordinances in certain situations

Situation	Discretionary Power	Controversial Examples
Appointment of CM	When no party has clear majority — Governor can invite the largest party/coalition/stability-first	Goa (2015, 2019), Maharashtra (2019)
Dismissal of CM	If CM loses majority — Governor can recommend dismissal and President's Rule	Karnataka (2023) — tense situation but averted
Art. 356 recommendation	Governor can recommend President's Rule if state govt fails	Kerala (1959), Arunachal (2016), Punjab (2023, farm laws)
Reserving Bill for President	If bill threatens constitutional position of HC or other provisions	Many states — bills on CAA, farm laws, religious conversions
Withholding/returning bills	Can return a bill for reconsideration (except money bills)	TN (neet exemption bills repeatedly); Kerala (various bills)
President's Rule (Art. 356)	Exercised on Governor's report — the most controversial power	History of partisan misuse

Commission	Recommendations on Governor
Sarkaria Commission (1988)	Governor should not be an active politician; appointment after consultation with CM; removal only by impeachment-like process; 5-year tenure should be assured; give reasons for discretion
Punchhi Commission (2010)	Specific qualifications needed; fixed 5-year term; time limit for assent to bills; consult CM on appointment; remove "doctrine of pleasure" ambiguity; Governor should not be dismissable at will

Fact	Detail
Governor's normal tenure	5 years (at President's pleasure)
Minimum age for Governor	35 years (Art. 157)
Discretionary power is implicit	Not explicitly listed in one place — derived from Art. 163(1), 200, 356
Sarkaria Commission	1988 — most comprehensive review of Centre-State relations
Punchhi Commission	2010 — updated recommendations on Governor's role
No. of times Art. 356 used	Over 130 times (1950-present) — highest misuse

Year	Question	Type
2023	"The discretionary powers of the Governor have been a source of controversy. Discuss with examples."	Mains
2022	"The Governor is both the constitutional head and an agent of the Centre. Critically examine."	Mains
2021	Which Article empowers the Governor to reserve bills for the President?	Prelims
2020	"Sarkaria Commission recommendations on the Governor remain largely unimplemented. Analyse."	Mains
2019	"Discuss the role of the Governor in the appointment of the Chief Minister when no party has a clear majority."	Mains
2018	The Governor can be removed by?	Prelims

Statement	Truth Value	Why?
"The Governor is elected by the state legislature"	False	The Governor is appointed by the President (Art. 155)
"The Governor must accept the advice of the Council of Ministers in all matters"	False	Art. 163(1) says Ministers "aid and advise" — except where discretion is required by the Constitution
"The Governor can grant pardons for offences against state law"	True	Article 161 — pardon power for state subjects; but death sentence pardons are with the President (Art. 72)
"The Governor's tenure is fixed at 5 years"	False	5 years is the normal tenure — but the Governor holds office at the pleasure of the President (Art. 156) and can be removed earlier
"The Punchhi Commission recommended fixed tenure for Governors"	True	The Punchhi Commission (2010) recommended a fixed 5-year term and removal only through a process similar to impeachment

Mistake	Correction
"The Governor is a purely ceremonial head"	The Governor has substantial residual powers — especially under Art. 163, 200, 356
"The Governor can dismiss the CM at will"	Dismissal is only when the CM loses majority — the floor test is the proper test, not the Governor's perception
"All Governor's actions require ministerial advice"	Discretionary powers are exceptions — appointment of CM (hung house), President's Rule recommendation, reserving bills
"Governor's tenure is guaranteed for 5 years"	The Governor holds office at the President's pleasure (Art. 156) — removable without cause
"Money bills can be returned by the Governor"	The Governor cannot return a money bill — must give assent or refer to the President (Art. 200)

Governor
├── Appointment: President (Art. 155), 5 yrs (Art. 156), "pleasure" tenure
├── Powers:
│   ├── Executive: Appoint CM/ministers, AG, PSC
│   ├── Legislative: Summon/prorogue, nominate, dissolve, reserve bills (Art. 200)
│   ├── Financial: Budget, SFC
│   ├── Judicial: Pardon (Art. 161) — state subjects
│   └── Ordinance (Art. 213)
├── Discretionary Powers:
│   ├── CM appointment (hung house)
│   ├── CM dismissal (majority lost)
│   ├── Art. 356 recommendation
│   ├── Bill reservation (Art. 200)
│   └── Withholding/returning bills
├── Commissions: Sarkaria (1988), Punchhi (2010) — fixed tenure, qualifications, consult CM
├── Recent SC judgments: TN (2023), Punjab (2024) — Governor can't stall bills
└── Core Debate: Constitutional head vs. Agent of Centre

Governor: Powers, Discretion, and Controversies

TOPIC CLASSIFICATION

EXAMINER REASONING

Core Concept

Read Next

Governor: Powers, Discretion, and Controversies

TOPIC CLASSIFICATION

EXAMINER REASONING

Core Concept

Read Next

Key Facts

PYQ Table

Statement Elimination Guide

Current Affairs Hook

Interlinkages

Common Mistakes

Revision Snapshot

Source Notes